Menu of The Tavern Company in Cleveland Heights, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

The Tavern Company, nestled on Lee Road in Cleveland Heights, is a standout bar & grill destination that masterfully blends classic pub fare with an inviting neighborhood vibe. From the moment you step inside, it's clear this is a place where good food and community spirit converge.

The menu shines brightest in its hearty, well-executed comfort food, anchored by their Buffalo Wings and Fish and Chips, which are often hailed as must-tries. The wings burst with just the right balance of heat and tang, served with a cool blue cheese or ranch dip that perfectly complements their spicy kick. Their Fish and Chips come with Tavern Fries and a malt vinegar aioli, showcasing a traditional pairing elevated with thoughtful, house-crafted sauces that add nuance without overpowering.

Burger enthusiasts will find a rewarding selection here. The Bacon Burger and Onion Rings, as well as the classic Burger and Fries, deliver big on flavor with savory, juicy patties accompanied by crispy, golden sides. The Scotch on the Rocks and Steak-N-Bacon offerings extend beyond the basics, hinting at a robust palate that appreciates nuanced seasoning and quality ingredients.

Sandwich options such as the Mama’s Meatball Sub with tavern marinara and provolone are rich and comforting, highlighting soulful, Italian-inspired flair. The Soft Shell Crab Poboy, adorned with slaw and creole mayo, injects a Southern zest that contrasts nicely with the more traditional menu items. Unique creations like the Washington & Lee sandwich blend smoked mozzarella, brie, and apple with prosciutto for a balance of sweet, smoky, and tart notes.

Small bites, including the Mussels with roasted garlic, bacon, and tomatoes served alongside grilled bread, offer a delightful mélange of flavors that showcase kitchen creativity without losing grounding in comfort. Similarly, the Point Judith Calamari incorporates an unexpected sweet chili garlic and mango twist, adding a bright, tropical flair that surprises the palate.

The Tavern Company not only excels in food but also shines through its atmosphere and service. Reviews consistently highlight the staff’s warmth and attentiveness, especially at happy hour, creating a welcoming environment that keeps locals coming back. The expansive patio space mentioned by patrons provides an excellent backdrop for leisurely dining and socializing. Though some note a shift under new ownership, the enduring charm lies in the consistent quality of the fare and the community feel.

Overall, The Tavern Company’s menu strikes a harmonious chord between traditional bar fare and inventive dishes. Their weekly specials keep the experience fresh and exciting, while signature highlights such as the wings, burgers, and unique sandwiches solidify its reputation as a culinary mainstay on Cleveland’s East Side. Whether seeking a casual bite with friends or a relaxed hangout with fine bourbon in hand, this spot delivers on all fronts with an honest, robust menu and a lively, approachable atmosphere.